Controversy Analysis Worksheet
from Clabaugh & Rozycki Analyzing Controversy
Pre-analysis (form, partisanship)
1. Can you state the apparent controversy as a yes-no question?
2. Are there representatives for both sides of the issue?
Problems of Understanding (slogans, reifications, definitions, pseudo-solutions, name-calling, presuppositions.)
3. What are the critical terms upon which this controversy hinges?
Problems of Fact (Feelings, etc. ; Authority, Operationalizing, Inquiry Blockers)
a. Give the definitions on which there seems to be consensus.
b. Are there other problems of understanding?
4. What are the issues of fact underlying this controversy?
a. What sources of fact (authorities) are recognized by both parties?
b. Are there other issues relating to fact that need clarification?
Problems of Value (Fact & value, benefits & costs, responsibility)
5. What issues of value are there which relate to this controversy?
Meta-analysis ( logical errors, problems with consensus, commitments to a special theory of society, agendas maintaining conflict)
6. Are there metaproblems?